Building Passive Income

Episode 108 – Cash-on-Cash Return vs. Cap Rate: Which Metrics Matter Most?

00:00 / 00:17:05

Episode Description

In this episode of Building Passive Income, CREI Collin explains two of the most important metrics in real estate investing: cash-on-cash return and cap rate.

Although these metrics are often discussed together, they measure different aspects of an investment. Understanding how each calculation works—and when to use it—can help investors compare opportunities, evaluate financing, and make more informed purchasing decisions.

Learn how cap rate measures property performance, why cash-on-cash return reflects actual returns after financing, and how both metrics fit into a disciplined underwriting process.

What You’ll Learn

What cap rate measures
How to calculate cap rate
What cash-on-cash return measures
How financing affects investment returns
Positive vs. negative leverage
The relationship between cap rate and cash-on-cash return
Other important investment metrics
Common underwriting mistakes
How CREI Partners evaluates investment opportunities
Why multiple metrics should be used together

Key Takeaways

What Is Cap Rate?

Capitalization rate, or cap rate, measures a property’s income relative to its purchase price.

The basic formula is:

Net Operating Income (NOI) ÷ Purchase Price

Cap rate helps investors:

Compare similar properties
Evaluate pricing
Analyze market trends
Estimate potential income performance

Because financing is excluded, cap rate focuses on the property’s operating performance rather than the investor’s financing strategy.

Why Cap Rates Vary

Cap rates are not the same in every market.

They may vary based on:

Property location
Asset quality
Market conditions
Tenant demand
Property type
Perceived investment risk

A higher cap rate may indicate greater income relative to price, but it can also reflect higher risk or different market conditions.

Cap Rate Limitations

Although cap rate is valuable, it has limitations.

Cap rate does not account for:

Financing terms
Debt service
Closing costs
Capital expenditures
Reserve planning
Future appreciation

Cap rate should be considered alongside other financial metrics rather than used in isolation.

What Is Cash-on-Cash Return?

Cash-on-cash return measures the annual cash flow generated compared to the total cash invested.

The basic formula is:

Annual Cash Flow ÷ Total Cash Invested

Total cash invested may include:

Down payment
Closing costs
Initial repairs
Renovation expenses

Many cash-flow-focused investors place significant emphasis on cash-on-cash return because it reflects returns after financing.

Why Financing Matters

One of the biggest differences between cap rate and cash-on-cash return is financing.

Leverage can significantly affect investor returns.

Positive leverage may increase returns when financing costs are favorable relative to property performance.

Negative leverage can reduce returns when financing costs exceed the property’s income potential.

Because of this relationship, financing assumptions play a critical role in investment analysis.

Cash-on-Cash Return vs. Cap Rate

When comparing cash-on-cash return vs. cap rate, remember:

Cap rate evaluates the property.

Cash-on-cash return evaluates the investment from the investor’s perspective.

Both metrics are valuable, but they answer different questions.

Understanding both creates a more complete picture of an investment opportunity.

Real-World Examples

Throughout the episode, CREI Collin walks through several practical examples showing how financing affects returns.

Examples include:

All-cash purchases
Favorable financing
Higher-interest financing

These scenarios are educational illustrations designed to demonstrate how leverage changes investment performance.

Other Important Investment Metrics

Professional investors often analyze additional performance metrics, including:

Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR)
Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM)
Return on Investment (ROI)
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

Each metric provides different information and should be evaluated within the broader investment analysis.

Which Metrics Matter Most?

At CREI Partners, multiple metrics are reviewed together rather than relying on a single number.

Our investment philosophy places significant emphasis on:

Cash-on-cash return
Cap rate
Debt Service Coverage Ratio
Market fundamentals
Cash flow projections

Using multiple metrics provides a more balanced evaluation than relying on one calculation alone.

Common Mistakes Investors Make

Common mistakes include:

Relying solely on seller-provided cap rates
Ignoring financing assumptions
Comparing different markets without context
Forgetting closing costs and renovation expenses
Overestimating future income
Underestimating operating expenses

Independent verification and conservative assumptions remain essential.

Building a Better Investment Analysis

No single metric tells the entire story.

Strong underwriting combines:

Cap rate
Cash-on-cash return
DSCR
Property condition
Market analysis
Cash flow projections
Risk assessment

The strongest investment decisions consider both quantitative and qualitative factors.

CREI Partners’ Investment Philosophy

At CREI Partners, investment decisions begin with disciplined underwriting.

Our process focuses on:

Conservative assumptions
Positive cash flow
Strong market fundamentals
Independent verification
Long-term value creation

We believe cash-on-cash return is particularly useful for investors seeking consistent passive income while cap rate provides important context when evaluating property pricing and market opportunities.

Episode Highlights

[00:00] Introduction to cap rate and cash-on-cash return

[02:00] Understanding cap rate

[05:00] Cap rate limitations

[08:00] Understanding cash-on-cash return

[11:00] Positive and negative leverage

[14:00] Comparing both metrics

[17:00] Real-world examples

[20:00] Other important investment metrics

[23:00] Common investor mistakes

[26:00] CREI’s underwriting philosophy

Resources Mentioned

Cash-on-Cash Return Calculator
Cap Rate Calculator
Commercial Real Estate Underwriting Templates
DSCR Resources
Investment Analysis Worksheets

Let’s Talk

Interested in learning how CREI Partners evaluates multifamily investment opportunities using disciplined underwriting?

Schedule a call with our team:

https://calendly.com/shelbi-creipartners/30min

Subscribe & Review

If you’re enjoying Building Passive Income, subscribe and leave a review.

Your support helps us continue educating investors on commercial real estate and passive income.

Next Episode

In Episode 109, CREI Collin explains the 1% rule, the 50% rule, the Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM), and other quick screening tools that can help investors evaluate opportunities before completing detailed underwriting.

Disclaimer

This podcast is for educational purposes only and should not be considered legal, tax, financial, or investment advice. Always conduct your own due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making investment decisions.

Keywords

cash-on-cash return vs cap rate, cap rate explained, cash-on-cash return, rental property analysis, real estate investing metrics, investment property analysis, cap rate calculation, cash flow investing, DSCR, gross rent multiplier, multifamily investing, commercial real estate underwriting